Last week, Avinash Kaushik said, “The best way to make a Super Bowl ad effective is through ‘spike and sustain’ marketing.”
He also explained that releasing teasers, ads, and extended versions before the Big Game is part of the “sustain” strategy, building momentum ahead of the “spike” in viewership.
Super Bowl LIX drew 113 million viewers, according to Nielsen.
Many brands embraced this strategy, unveiling their commercials early to build buzz and maximize exposure.
By midday Sunday, more than 40 ads had already been released, and several organizations had analyzed those aired before Feb. 9.
Pre-game Super Bowl ads that made an impact
For example, iSpot.tv identified “Budweiser | Super Bowl LIX ‘First Delivery’” as the early winner based on consumer surveys.
A young Clydesdale foal, eager to join the Budweiser delivery team, is told he’s too young. While the other horses depart, a keg falls off the wagon unnoticed.
The foal, determined to prove himself, embarks on a long journey, pushing the keg through various obstacles.
He successfully delivers the keg to the bar, interrupting a “horse walks into a bar” joke and impressing the driver who had dismissed him earlier.
The foal is rewarded with recognition and a sense of accomplishment.
“Somebody | It Takes All of Us SB LIX,” which features players mentoring kids, was the most emotionally resonant and attention-grabbing Super Bowl ad released before the Big Game, according to DAIVID.
It evoked intense positive emotions in over half of viewers, particularly feelings of warmth, inspiration, and pride, all significantly higher than the U.S. average.
The ad also held viewers’ attention better than average ads, both at the beginning and the end.
And Sprout Social‘s social media analysis showed strong performance for “A Century of Cravings | Uber Eats.”
Their successful celebrity-filled advertisement features Matthew McConaughey, Charli XCX, and Martha Stewart and cleverly incorporates the stadium’s name into a joke about Stewart’s Caesar salad.
The best Super Bowl ads released during the Big Game
Some of the roughly 80 Super Bowl spots cost a record $8 million for 30 seconds this year, per the Associated Press.
The granddaddy of rating TV commercials during the Big Game, “Budweiser | Super Bowl LIX ‘First Delivery’” ranked no. 1 with a score of 3.56 out of 5, according to USA Today’s Ad Meter. (Kudos to iSpot.tv for picking this winner ahead of time.)
In second spot was “LAY’S | The Little Farmer | :60,” with a score of 3.55. As the video’s description says, “One little potato. One big dream.”
In third place was “The ULTRA Hustle | Super Bowl LIX | Michelob ULTRA” with a score of 3.52.
As the ad’s description declares, “You can’t out-hustle a hustler. Willem Dafoe, Catherine O’Hara, Sabrina Ionescu, Randy Moss, and Ryan Crouser.”
In fourth position was “Stella Artois | David & Dave: The Other David” with a score of 3.51.
So, David Beckham goes to meet his long-lost twin, played by Matt Damon.
What do they have in common? “A love for Stella? Fancy footwork?”
Ranked fifth with a score of 3.49 was “Somebody | It Takes All of Us SB LIX.” Congrats to DAIVID for picking this winner ahead of time.
It’s also worth noting that “A Century of Cravings | Uber Eats” finished no. 8 in the USA Today Ad Meter rankings. Sprout Social’s analysis of social media was in the ballpark.
Get the newsletter search marketers rely on.
Alternative metrics for evaluating Super Bowl ads
There are other ways to measure the top ads released during Super Bowl 2025.
For example, DAIVID used its AI-powered platform to analyze 65 Super Bowl ads aired Sunday night, predicting their emotional impact and effectiveness.
Their AI models combine facial coding, eye tracking, survey data, computer vision, and even listening APIs.
“Somebody | It Takes All of Us SB LIX” was not only the most emotionally engaging ad of the 40+ spots released before the Big Game, but it also generated the most intense positive emotions of the 65 ads shown during Sunday’s Super Bowl broadcast.
The ad attracted the highest attention levels of any spot shown.
In second place was “Jeep | Big Game | Harrison Ford x Jeep | Owner’s Manual.”
As the video’s description acknowledges:
“Life doesn’t come with an owner’s manual – you have to write your own. And no one knows this better than Harrison Ford.”
The ad attracted an intense positive emotional response from 54.2% of viewers, according to DAIVID.
In third was “What is Greatness?” from He Get Us.
The video’s description asks:
“Is being great, as our society defines it, really that great? Or is greatness quite the opposite of what we think it is? In this video, we explore how Jesus redefined true greatness and what it might mean for us. All of us.”
And 53.3% of people had intense positive emotional responses.
“Own the Dream | Rocket” ranked fourth. The video’s description clearly states:
“Everyone deserves their shot at the American Dream.”
This generated intense positive emotional responses with 52.6% of people.
In fifth place was “Pfizer | Big Game Commercial 2025 | Knock Out.”
As the video’s description explains, “Pfizer is fighting for 8 cancer breakthroughs by 2030.” This triggered intense positive emotional responses from 52.3% of people.
It’s also worth noting that “LAY’S | The Little Farmer | :60” ranked no. 8 and “Budweiser | Super Bowl LIX ‘First Delivery’” ranked no. 10 in DAIVID’s list of Top 10 Most Emotionally Engaging Super Bowl 2025 ads.
Different methodologies can still yield similar results.
However, DAIVID’s post-game analysis yielded significantly different insights than USA Today’s.
Super Bowl 2025 ads were the least effective in five years, per DAIVID’s Creative Effectiveness Score.
The average ad scored 6.2 out of 10, the lowest since 2020, generating less attention and positive emotion than previous years.
While many advertisers aimed for humor, serious and purpose-driven ads dominated the top 10, with the NFL’s “Somebody” ad being the most emotionally engaging.
Ian Forrester, DAIVID’s CEO and founder, observed:
“With the vast majority of Super Bowl advertisers trying to make us laugh this year, it’s interesting that brands that stepped away from the usual Super Bowl celebrity/humor trope have attracted the most positivity. It shows just how hard it is to cut-through when so many are trying the same approach. With overall effectiveness also down, maybe it’s time brands tried something different to get people’s attention on game day.”
What’s next: Insights beyond the Big Game
In the coming days, digital marketers can expect more rankings from Kantar, System1, and other organizations analyzing the impact of Big Game ads on both performance and branding.
These insights matter because metrics like Brand Life and Engaged-View Key Events can serve as KPIs for “spike and sustain” campaigns beyond the Super Bowl – whether for back-to-school season, Thanksgiving, or a major product launch.
Contributing authors are invited to create content for Search Engine Land and are chosen for their expertise and contribution to the search community. Our contributors work under the oversight of the editorial staff and contributions are checked for quality and relevance to our readers. The opinions they express are their own.